Current:Home > reviewsEthics probe into North Carolina justice’s comments continues after federal court refuses to halt it -Wealthify
Ethics probe into North Carolina justice’s comments continues after federal court refuses to halt it
View
Date:2025-04-16 08:10:43
RALEIGH, N.C. (AP) — An ethics probe into a Black state court justice’s comments about diversity will move forward after a federal judge denied her request to halt the investigation she says is quashing her right to free speech.
Associate Justice Anita Earls, a Democrat, sued the North Carolina Judicial Standards Commission in August, alleging their investigations have chilled her First Amendment rights and disrupted her work. Her lawyers asked a federal court to halt the panel’s activities while her lawsuit goes to trial.
But U.S. District Judge William Osteen denied the request late Tuesday, writing that a justice’s speech carries greater weight than average citizens. The state has a legitimate interest in protecting the authority and integrity of the court, wrote Osteen, who was nominated to the federal bench by Republican President George W. Bush.
Earls, one of two Democrats on the seven-member Supreme Court, will appeal the decision to the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, her attorney said.
“The opinion is contrary to established legal precedent on the role of federal courts in guaranteeing the freedom of speech,” said attorney Press Millen following the ruling.
Earls is the only Black member of the state’s highest court. She was elected as justice in 2018 after a long career in civil rights and voting law and has often come to loggerheads with her Republican colleagues.
She filed her lawsuit two weeks after a commission staff attorney wrote her a letter saying the panel was going to investigate her over an interview with legal news outlet Law360. In it, she had discussed the Supreme Court’s decision to end a commission looking at fairness and equity in the state court system and what she considered a lack of minority judicial clerks.
“I really do think implicit bias is at play,” she said, according to the Law360 article, adding that “there have been cases where I have felt very uncomfortable on the bench because I feel like my colleagues are unfairly cutting off a female advocate,” including one who was Black.
That interview also appears to allege that her Republican colleagues have acted out of political bias in some of their decision-making, the commission attorney said in the letter to Earls.
The commission argued in federal court that her lawsuit should be dismissed, citing a legal doctrine that discourages federal courts from hearing a case that could interfere with the authority of state courts.
Scores of civil rights advocates and Black legislators have come to Earls’ defense, saying she should be praised for speaking out about racism and sexism in the courts, but that she’s otherwise being singled out as a Black female jurist.
Members of the commission, composed of judges and non-attorneys picked by the chief justice, legislative leaders and the governor, can recommend to the Supreme Court that a judge receive anything from a public reprimand to suspension or removal from office. Or it can issue a private letter of caution on its own.
Earls has become a foil to the court’s new Republican majority, which includes Chief Justice Paul Newby. She has criticized in dissenting opinions decisions by GOP colleagues to reconsider rulings by the previous Democratic majority that had struck down photo voter identification and gerrymandered voting maps. Her seat is up for reelection in 2026.
Since the lawsuit was filed, the Republican-controlled General Assembly has adjusted the commission’s composition so that GOP leaders now choose six of the 14 members, not two.
veryGood! (236)
Related
- The Super Bowl could end in a 'three
- Weird Al on accordions, bathrooms, and getting turned down by Prince
- Lucy Hale Reflects on Eating Disorder Battle and Decade-Long Sobriety Journey
- 'Some Like It Hot' leads with 13 Tony Award nominations
- South Korea's acting president moves to reassure allies, calm markets after Yoon impeachment
- 'The Three of Us' tracks a married couple and the wife's manipulative best friend
- #FindTheKetchupBoatGuy success: Heinz locates the man who survived nearly a month at sea by eating ketchup and seasonings
- 3 works in translation tell science-driven tales
- Macy's says employee who allegedly hid $150 million in expenses had no major 'impact'
- Hague people's court seeks accountability from Putin for crimes against Ukraine
Ranking
- A White House order claims to end 'censorship.' What does that mean?
- China says it organized troops after U.S. spy plane flew over Taiwan Strait
- Ballroom dancer and longtime 'Dancing With The Stars' judge Len Goodman dies at 78
- Vanderpump Rules' Tom Sandoval Calls Lala Kent a Bully Who Needs a Hobby as Feud Heats Up
- Whoopi Goldberg is delightfully vile as Miss Hannigan in ‘Annie’ stage return
- Soccer Star Alex Morgan Deserves Another Gold Medal for Her Latest History-Making Milestone
- 'Are You There God?' adaptation retains the warmth and wit of Judy Blume's classic
- Your Favorite Clothing Brand Has the Cutest Affordable Home Goods for Spring
Recommendation
Most popular books of the week: See what topped USA TODAY's bestselling books list
Soccer Star Alex Morgan Deserves Another Gold Medal for Her Latest History-Making Milestone
Why Selena Gomez Initially Deleted This Sexy Photo of Herself
Comic Roy Wood Jr. just might be the host 'The Daily Show' (and late night TV) need
DeepSeek: Did a little known Chinese startup cause a 'Sputnik moment' for AI?
Lucy Hale Reflects on Eating Disorder Battle and Decade-Long Sobriety Journey
It Cosmetics Flash Deal: Get $123 Worth of Products for Just $77
Harry Belafonte, singer, actor and activist, has died at age 96